Fulltext search in archive
Results 151 to 180 of 5954:
Opportunities of the Ministry of Defence in Promoting the Framework Nations ConceptReviewed - Reviewplk. gšt. Ing. Ondřej Havel, Ing. Antonín Novotný, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 35-54 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.04.035-054 After several years of reducing of the Czech defence budget there is a reversal and the Czech MoD begins to manage the increased budget especially for Czech Armed Forces capability development. The Czech Armed Forces is for many years actively involved in the process sharing multi-national capabilities of NATO. Among the former activities such as Smart Defence and Connected Forces Initiative, is also initiative Framework Nations Concept. This article analyzes the overall framework of this initiative, direction and development of this concept. |
De-escalation of the War at Ukraine, and Its Resolution by International Security Organisations.Reviewed - ReviewIng. Zbyněk Dubský, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 3-20 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.03.003-020 The article is aimed on the identification of the tools of the international security organisations (NATO, European Union, Organisation for security and Cooperation in Europe) for de-escalation and resolution of the violent conflict in Ukraine. It is based on the liberal institucionalism. It characterizes and systematises tools and divides it into "soft power" and "hard power" tools. It is analysed the possibility of the use of armed forces as a coercive tool or in peacekeeping or monitoring missions. The NATO and the EU became involved in coercive diplomacy, the OSCE as a "soft power" becomes involved in mediation of the conflict in eastern Ukraine and dispatched long time missions. All three analysed organisations used the tools without placing of armed forces. |
Lessons Learned Process as a Part of Management Process in the Defense SectorReviewed - Reviewpplk. Ing. Janka KOSECOVÁVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 46-60 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.03.046-060 The Lessons Learned from the military operations and exercises as a system and process was introduced to the Czech Armed Forces in 2004. Since this time, it become a standard component of command and control, and one of the tools that generates impulses on the development of capability of the units and staffs, at all levels. The article discusses not only the achievements but focusing on the barriers that hinder effective development system and the lessons learned process. In the first part of the article, this loosely follows the article, published in issue 1/2015 magazine Vojenské rozhledy - Czech Military Rewiev, the authors focused on the basic principles of the process. The focus of the article is to analyse the current state of the lessons learned process with result, that one of the main problems is the misunderstanding of the process by some commanders and also analysis of the lessons identified on the strategic level. At the end of the text, the authors presented recommendations on how to overcome the identified barriers and ensure the further optimization of the process. |
Documents of Strategic Defence ManagementReviewed - Reviewplk. gšt. Ing. Miroslav Havelka, Ing. Josef Procházka, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 3-19 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.02.003-019 Effective strategic management is determined by several factors. Firstly, it is influenced by knowledge, experience and skills of all stakeholdersresponsible for preparation of strategic decisions and decision taking. Secondary and no less importantly, it depends on the quality of internal business processes dealing with all aspects of defence policy formulation and execution. Outputs from strategic management are strategic, conceptual, planning and evaluating documents. This article offers hierarchy of strategic documents defines their purpose and content and outlines responsibilities for their elaboration. Recommendations reflect assessment of current legal and procedural framework, strategic management theory and best practise. Ambition is to propos for consideration one of many possible solutions in order to reinforce strategic defence management. |
Scenarios in Capabilities Planning ProcessReviewed - ReviewIng. Josef Procházka, PhD., Ing. František Mičánek, Doc. Ing. Jozef Šmondrk, PhD., pplk. Ing. Josef MelicharVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 44-60 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.25.2016.01.044-060 The aim of the article is to bring inspiration and offer needed recommendations for implementing the scenarios in the defence planning process. The article addresses purpose, development and practical application of scenarios in a national defence planning process, utilizing capability based planning (National Capability Based Defence Planning - NCBDP). During the planning scenarios are used for identification and verification of capability requirements. Scenarios depict main features of the environment in which the armed forces will be employed to execute military missions. Scenarios reflect as well operational concepts in a sense of doctrinal use of armed forces. Furthermore, they offer a possibility to identify and quantify required capabilities in a volatile, difficult to predict, complex, permanently and dynamically changing environment, and reduce level of uncertainty and associated risks. In this regard, scenarios are significant analytical and supporting tool of defence planning with high value added. Correct application of scenarios allows defining a set of required capabilities necessary for success in potential future conflicts. Scenarios enable long-term planning of capabilities development and optimisation as a platform for qualified and well informed decisions at the MoD level on the armed forces character, structure and size with regard to the ambitions and international commitments of the country. In the conclusion the article brings recommendations for the defence planning process improvement by exploiting capability based planning and scenarios. Recommendations provided in the article include doctrinal changes, organizational changes within MoD and General staff, recommendations for updating the education plans for military personnel, recommendations for optimization of the defence planning process as well as for necessary changes in the approach of the defence managers and military leaders to the described method. |
A Vision of Geospatial Support to Ministry of Defence 2014-2018Nonreviewed - OtherPodplukovník Ing. Jan Marša, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2013, Vol. XXII. (LIV.): 105-112 The paper briefly identified the long-time objectives of overall geospatial support. Based on that, ways ahead to achieve main aims are described. Special attention is paid to software platform for geospatial production, cooperation with civilian and international partners, legal aspects, R&D as well as mobile sets intended usage. |
Armed Forces Capability TheoryReviewed - ReviewDoc. Ing. Milan Kubeša, CSc., pplk. Ing. Radek Dubec, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2013, Vol. XXII. (LIV.): 41-51 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.22.2013.03.041-051 The paper presents reflections over the issue of armed forces capabilities. It is a phenomenon much discussed and written earlier, namely from the point of its building, estimation and development. Nevertheless the question is whether practical experiences are backed by theory fundamentals. Now we have a chance to introduce the live theory of quality management [1] into this specific and frequented military problem. The article is a polemic consideration over possibilities of introducing capabilities management into command and control capabilities system in armed forces. |
Some Aspects of Term of Decontamination Perception on Both National and Alliance LevelsReviewed - ReviewPodplukovník Ing. Pavel Otřísal, Ph.D., MBAVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2013, Vol. XXII. (LIV.): 67-75 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.22.2013.03.067-075 The classification of a term of "decontamination" comes out not only from the Alliance norms, national military regulations and publications, but also from the documents that deal with the conception of decontamination for civilian purposes, i.e. from documents of the Fire Rescue Brigades of the Czech Republic. The study of both Alliance and national documents has proved that in many cases this term is being introduced in a different way which might cause not very homogenous interpretation and understanding to accomplished decontamination measurements and thus even overall disunity in a framework not only of Alliance, but also in selected basic and other parts of the Integrated Rescue System of the Czech Republic. The paper analyses approaches to the term of "decontamination"practically only by means of definitions in use nowadays. At the end of this document there are recommendations which ought be considered by the management of the Czech Armed Forces Chemical Corps within the area of its respective interest. |
The Goals of Civil-Military Cooperation in the Context of White Paper on DefenceReviewed - ReviewIng. Pavel Zona, Ph.D., Ing. Vlastimil Galatík, CSc.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2013, Vol. XXII. (LIV.): 31-38 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.22.2013.02.031-038 This paper deals with the activities of the Armed Forces of the Czech Republic, under national command on its own territory, with the emphasis to the activities of civil-military cooperation (CIMIC) components. It puts stress on the issue of forces operations, those of CIMIC units in particular, within the Integrated Rescue System, during crisis situations, i.e. natural disasters, environmental accidents, etc. The paper comes out from the tasks defined by the Defence White Paper. Those tasks are compared with the legislation in effect, and the authors make some inquiries about suitable measures to implement them. Unlike missions carried out abroad, the CIMIC problems and tasks in ACR operations on home territory are nearly untouched. The paper aims to open discussion over this topic, among others, because our current relevant legislation is obsolete. |
Military DeceptionMilitary artIng. Jaroslav KulíšekVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2012, Vol. XXI. (LIII.): 40-58 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.21.2012.02.040-058 The purpose of this article is to inform on elements of military deception in NATO armies and overarching principles that make military deception successful. Deception Planning is an iterative process that should be considered as an inextricable part of the operational planning. The knowledge in the field of military deception in the Czech military is low; no operational deception plan has been prepared for foreign operations or any military exercise. Deception is widely appreciated as a powerful instrument of military operations, yet it is surprisingly neglected by both the Czech Army and Military Educational System. The author tries to encourage officers and members of higher staffs to study this subject. |
Russian Involvement in the Conflict in Eastern Ukraine Over the Period April 2014 - February 2015 (Part 1)Reviewed - Reviewmjr. Ing. Tomáš HalačkaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 55-73 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.04.055-073 This study deals with selected aspects of the conflict in Eastern Ukraine in Luhansk and Donetsk region in period of April 2014 - to February 2015. Study is divided in two subsequent articles. The first article consists of introduction, theoretic-methodological part, analytical part and short summary, which defines main features of Russians engagement in the conflict. Theoretic-methodological part deals with terminological, theoretical and methodological background of analysis, including generally approach of Russian federation to security policy. Analytical part is divided in to the two partial chapters. The first deals with main Russian objective in the conflict. The second deals with the phases of Russian engagement. |
Strategic Documents of the Czech Republic and Ministry of Defence AcquisitionsReviewed - ReviewIng. Antonín Novotný, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 21-32 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.03.021-032 This article aims to reflect a digression into the history of selected strategic documents, which processed the Ministry of Defence or was in the processing involved - in connection to the planning of acquisitions. The ambition of the article is not a comprehensive evaluation process, but only the selected aspects. After many years of decreasing Czech defence budget, is here the opposite situation. In connection with the new situation it is necessary to rethink the current approach to this topic; to ensure maximal security of the Czech Republic and in a figurative sense NATO and the European Union also. The fact, that the Czech strategy document was among the best in the EU, does not mean that defence spending is automatically efficient. |
The Legality of the Military Police Activities by Granting Aid as a Host Nation Support OperationReviewBrig. gen. JUDr. Pavel Kříž, LL.M., Mgr. Ing. Leopold Skoruša, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 33-45 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.03.033-045 The paper deals with the principle of legality during putting in practice of Military police support to allied armed forces in the Host nation Support operation on the Czech Republic territory. Security of sending nation armed forces weaknesses have been identified on the base of analysis of the issue current state supplemented by the legal framework assessment. Suggestions, for expert discussion of Military police authority change, are in the last chapter. |
Save Money or Keep Czech Armed Forces Functional?Nonreviewed - Othernpor. Mgr. Tomáš KučeraVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 113-119 The fundamental regulation of governmental invests is Czech Act on Public Contracts. Its main objective is a financial saving in the procurement of goods and services by the state. In some specific cases, this objective may come into a conflict with other interests protected by a law. Several verdicts recently delivered by courts in criminal cases relating to a procurement of medical supplies bring a new and interesting insight into this issue. Some conflicts with social interest were identified on basis of these verdicts. These interests are the maintaining of the Czech Republic Armed Forces combat capability and its function in peace-time, fulfilment of international obligations of the Czech Republic and the requirement for the strict adherence to military orders. Some cases, in which different interests outweigh the interest protected by the Act on Public Contracts, were found. |
Utilization of Scenarios for the Operational Concepts DevelopmentReviewed - Researchplk. gšt. Ing. Jan Marša, Ph.D., doc. Ing. Milan Kubeša, CSc.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 20-35 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.02.020-035 The paper deals with the issue of the purpose, creation and practical use of scenarios during operational concepts development. The scenar- ios reflect the fundamental characteristics of the environment in which the military missions will be conducted in the next 15-20 years. The paper defines the type of scenarios useful for creation of operational concepts and requirements that must be met for a successful process of scenarios development. Further, it describes the process of scenarios development, the main risks associated with this process while suggesting the possibility of reducing the rate of those risks. |
The Fight of France against ISIS in Iraq and Syria since Summer 2014 until March 2016Nonreviewed - OtherIveta KupkováVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 53-65 This article discusses political and military issue of Islamic State, since establishment of the antiIS alliance in summer 2014 until March 2016 in Iraq and Syria. The article describes each step made during this period separately or in alliance, while the terrorist attacks in Paris are considered as a turning point. That is the reason why the article is the comparison of French policy before and after the attacks. Furthermore, the crucial part is to resolve Syrian crisis in which France is actively involved in order to settle down the events in Syria and transform it into democratic country without President Assad.This article discusses political and military issue of Islamic State, since establishment of the antiIS alliance in summer 2014 until March 2016 in Iraq and Syria. The article describes each step made during this period separately or in alliance, while the terrorist attacks in Paris are considered as a turning point. That is the reason why the article is the comparison of French policy before and after the attacks. Furthermore, the crucial part is to resolve Syrian crisis in which France is actively involved in order to settle down the events in Syria and transform it into democratic country without President Assad. |
Morocco´s Foreign Fighters: Jihadists´ 2nd Generation and its Islamist IdeologyNonreviewed - OtherMgr. Jana KostrounováVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 82-90 There is currently about 1 500 Moroccan citizens fighting for the so-called Daech in Syria and Iraq; that makes the North African monarchy one of the main countries which export radical islam djihadists and supporters abroad to the war-beaten Syrian-Iraqi region. Until 2014 Moroccan officials let them leave the country almost freely, to be precise, they didn´t prevent them from travelling to Syria, Iraq and other proxy war destinations. That´s how have the Moroccan fighters joined the Daech rows fighting in the beginning against the Syrian president Asad. But it seems now that the situation has rapidly changed: the Kingdom of Morocco is currently fighting and closely monitoring its own foreign fighters who are coming back home. Especially such eventual threat is pushing the country for creating a new national security strategy related to this risky minority, which needs to be integrated back to the Moroccan society. |
State Service and Career Courses in the Armed Forces of the Slovak RepublicNonreviewed - Otherpplk. Ing. Petr MarekVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 91-108 The article informs about the state service of professional soldiers in the Armed Forces of the Czech Republic and the Slovak Republic. It compares the state service of professional soldiers in both countries mentioned and analyses the changes that took place in the Armed Forces of the Slovak Republic on January 1, 2016. With reference to the state service it deals with the career of professional soldiers in the Armed Forces of the Slovak Republic. It offers the list of current career courses in the Armed Forces of the Slovak Republic. It analyses and compares the career courses designed for officers of both countries. |
Chemical Corps Contribution to CBRN Exploitation and Forensics CapabilityNonreviewed - Otherkpt. Ing. Radim Zahradníček, pplk. doc. Ing. Pavel Otřísal, Ph.D., MBAVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 109-117 Proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, danger of misusage of toxic materials, terrorism and other phenomena of current security environment are factors that lead to the development of capabilities of the Chemical Corps. The paper is looking at the problem of collecting evidence and forensic attribution of responsibility for hostile acts. This capability is required by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and is supported by experience from military operations, which confirm the validity and significance of required changes. The article presents some recommendations that may lead to development of units that will contribute to the ability of collecting evidence and thus support forensics. |
Active Reserve of the Czech Republic - Present and PerspectivesNonreviewed - OtherTomáš HruškaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 118-124 This text sets its aim in analyzing the current state of active reserve in the Czech republic. The function, current state along with future plans as envisioned in the Concept of Active reserve from the year 2012 and relevant public anouncements of certain military and ministry officials will be described first. The ammendment to the conscription act will be briefly introduced along with its effects on the function of Active reserve, its perspectives and on the requirements on the recruits. Then the possible issues that may arise during the implementation of reforms will be analyzed. These lay mainly in the personal level and training. Several possible solutions for these issues will be put forward. |
Uvodni slovo NGS ACRNonreviewed - OtherVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 3-5 |
Black Sea Dimension of Ukraine WarReviewed - Reviewdoc. PhDr. Jan Eichler, CSc.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 6-23 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.25.2016.01.006-023 The article is based on the positions of neo-realism, namely in the works by S. Walt and J. Mearsheimer. It characterizes the key actors of the war in Ukraine, which is a result of a long-term geopolitical competition between the USA and RF in the Black Sea region. The NATO enlargement in the area is classified as a non-coercive Expansion by Invitation (articulated by the elites of the former member states of the USSR and Warsaw Pact), which has provoked growing irritation of Russian political and military elites and the following hybrid war with dramatic international consequences. Last but not least, the article analyses military incidents and resulting security threats and challenges. |
The Consequences of the Bundeswehr Mission in Afghanistan for German Military Engagement AbroadReviewed - ReviewPhDr. Pavel DvořákVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 24-43 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.25.2016.01.024-043 This article focuses on answering the question to what extent did the German foreign and security policy change, based on the ISAF mission in Afghanistan, especially when it comes to military deployment abroad. The author identifies and analyses the consequences associated with the German experience in Afghanistan and their influence on the current and future deployment of German armed forces abroad. The attention is given to the German strategic culture of "civilian power" and the question, if Germany still fulfills the attributes connected with this theoretical concept. The author verifies this assumption by means of the role theory concept, which helps to understand the behavior of Germany on the international level. |
Actionable Intelligence - Supporting Instrument for Commander's Decision-making ProcessReviewed - ReviewIng. Martin HavlíkVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 61-72 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.25.2016.01.061-072 This article describes the doctrinal determination and definitions of the term Actionable Intelligence and the impact of this specific intelligence concepton commander's decision-making process. The part of this report deals with the position of Actionable Intelligence in intelligence branch, concretely in connection with the intelligence disciplines and particular stages within intelligence cycle. There is also the accentuation of interconnection to the importance of intelligence information sharing, early warning systems and force protection on tactical level. The next part of this article is focused on the impact of intelligence support on commander's decision-making processes. |
Possibilities of Tactical Activities Optimization in the Framework of Engineer UnitsReviewed - ReviewDoc. Ing. Jaroslav ZELENÝ, CSc.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 91-101 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.25.2016.01.091-101 The article presents possible approaches to solve problems of finding the optimum state of tactical activities within the level of small Engineer Units. The intention is, by elaborating of the partial engineer goal which is focussed on the area of engineer units' tactics, to develop input data/ information needed for further development of mathematical models of the tactical activities. Subsequently, with the judgement on modelling outputs (applicability within C2 activities of staffs' task force structures) from engineer unit tactics point of view, the article contributes to enhancing all of C2 processes effectiveness. The article also provides us with information about the range of facts relative with problems of selected engineer unit (counter-mobility task forces) deployment planning, and controlling. There can be also found inventory of activities appropriate for optimization. |
Experience from Canceled Sajkovac Base Extend the Czech Armed Forces Engineer CapabilitiesNonreviewed - Reviewnpor. Ing. Jan Hanudeľ, plk. doc. Ing. Pavel Maňas Ph.D., mjr. Ing. Jiří Štoller Ph.D., pplk. v.z. Ing. Vojtěch HanudeľVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 102-113 The article deals with experience in closure of military bases in foreign operations. It follows in article Life cycle of military bases in foreign operations, published in Vojenské rozhledy Nr. 4/2009. The text of article presents current knowledge about the life cycle of military bases and general principles from the perspective of the latest NATO Handbook. The theoretical part of the article introduces weighting method of decision analysis, which compares current ways for the field bases closure. Authors describe findings from base closure Šajkovac that significantly influenced removal activities. |
Is the Czech Security System Complex Enough?Nonreviewed - OtherIng. Vladimír Karaffa, CSc.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 156-162 The Security System of the Czech Republic has gradually profiled since 1998 to the shape as it is generally defined and described in the final part of the Security Strategy of the Czech Republic (2015). The article is contemplation over some possibilities to further improvement of the system in terms of the current state and challenges arising from developments in the security environment and in terms of options, how to adequately respond to them. |
Adaptation of the Czech Republic Defence Policy and Strategy to the New Security ThreatsNonreviewed - ResearchIng. Josef Procházka, Ph.D., Ing. Vladimír Karaffa, CSc., PhDr. Libor Frank, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2015, Vol. XXIV. (LVI.): 8-22 This article deals with challenges for the defence policy and strategy of the Czech Republic and their further adaptation and. It outlines set of recommendations for ensuring its armed forces relevance and their long term sustainability. The article reflects debate during the international conference Defence and Strategy organised by the Centre of Security and Military Strategic Studies of the Defence University and held on 15-16 June 2015 in Brno. |
Cooperation of Civil and Military Logistics in Military OperationsReviewed - ReviewDoc. Ing. Miroslav Cempírek, CSc., Doc. Ing. Miroslav Pecina, CSc., Ing. Miroslav Musil, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2015, Vol. XXIV. (LVI.): 144-158 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.24.2015.03.144-158 The article deals with the integration of outside resources into the process of support Forces in Military operations. The crux of this work lies in the illustration of 'place' and the role of Civil Contracting Supports in the Combat Service system of Armed Forces. It also accentuates the sense and complexity of Combat Service Support. The article analyses the advantages. disadvantages and risks for utilizating Civil Contractors in armed conflicts. The text respects this and acknowledges the benefit from experience of the NATO Armies in this field. In the closing part the authors formulate recommendations for the later boom of 'Combat Service' theory and practice. The effect and benefit of this article lies first of all in its suggestion of criteria for the selection of contractors. |
International Contexts of War in UkraineReviewed - Reviewdoc. PhDr. Jan Eichler, CSc.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2015, Vol. XXIV. (LVI.): 5-19 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.24.2015.02.005-019 The article deals with the international context of the latent war in Ukraine. It explains the recent history of the post-Soviet area in the light of Galutng's theory of positive and negative peace. It continues by the annexation of the Crimean peninsula and its international consequences. At the same time, it examines key features of the debate in the USA as well as other NATO countries. It focuses also the debate about the livraison of arms to the Ukrainian government and explains the arguments of proponents as well of the opponents of this controversial project. |

