Fulltext search in archive
Results 181 to 210 of 2990:
French military interventions in MENAP countries during the 2010sReviewed - ReviewJan EichlerVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2023, Vol. XXXII. (LXIV.): 52-66 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.32.2023.02.052-066 The article is about six French Special Military Operations (SMOs) that were conducted in Islamic countries in the MENA region between 2011 and 2022. It provides an explanation of their historical, geopolitical, and military contexts while also assessing their compliance with international law. The text introduces two innovative concepts, the Holland doctrine and the Macron doctrine, and analyses both their successes and failures. Ultimately, the article concludes by addressing the question of why these SMOs achieved military success but failed to meet political objectives, resulting in a significant disillusionment among French political and military elites, as well as the participating soldiers. |
Humanitarian Transit Camp For Refugees. Construction and Operation Experiences.Nonreviewed - OtherVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2023, Vol. XXXII. (LXIV.): 119-134 An article describes a humanitarian camp at Mokraď in Slovakia, built up by the Czech Army in cooperation with the Armed Forces of Slovak republic, as a reaction on refugee crises caused by the war in Ukraine. All phases of the development, preparation, movement and transportation, construction and operation are mentioned there, an internal structure, used technical means and involvement of personnel, lessons identified and recommendations included, leading to increase of efficiency of similar activities in the future. |
Factors Shaping the Employment of Military Force from the Perspective of the War in UkraineReviewed - ReviewMichal Hrnčiar, Jaroslav KompanVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2023, Vol. XXXII. (LXIV.): 69-82 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.32.2023.01.069-082 The study presents a meritorious view of the traditional operational factors of space, time and force. On the background of the first and second phases of the War in Ukraine, it examines how the relevant factors shape the use of military force in operations, clarifies their mutual correlation, interference, application connections and also causality. The results of the study demonstrate the necessity of a correct and holistic perception of operational factors for effective deployment and employment of military forces in the contemporary operating environment. The main benefit of the study, applying the heuristic and inventive function of analogy from the open sources of available identified knowledge from the deployment of military forces in the War in Ukraine, is the mediation of model examples of a comprehensive vision of the effects of how operational factors shape the use of military force in contemporary high-intensity warfare operations. |
Integration of Women in Combat Operations and Warfare: Possibilities of Integration into Pakistan Armed ForcesReviewed - ReviewShamaila Amir, Saman ZaidVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2023, Vol. XXXII. (LXIV.): 83-97 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.32.2023.01.083-097 The participation of women in the armed forces creates many challenges to their integration in a masculine-dominated mechanism. Traditionally, military service embodies the macho culture where a certain type of physical strength is required, attainable only through the male frame. The traditional military personnel model represents a young male force that is supported by spouses who stay at home but modern warfare and the inclusion of technology have opened many chances for women to be included in the armed forces. Therefore, the aim of this paper is to highlight various fields of armed forces where women in Pakistan may or may not be suitable to be integrated. The paper descriptively analyzes the participation of women in armed forces in general and in the Pakistan Armed Forces in particular. Recommendations highlight the combat operations relevant to the Pakistan Armed Forces context which women can or cannot be integrated into. |
Vojtěch Němeček passed awayNonreviewed - OtherredakceVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2023, Vol. XXXII. (LXIV.): 143 |
Military Aspects of the War in UkraineReviewed - ReviewJán SpišákVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 103-118 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.04.103-118 The war in Ukraine has become a global issue that has been closely monitored and evaluated by military experts and the media since its beginning. The aim of this article is to point out some specific aspects of the development of the conflict in Ukraine in its initial stages. In the beginning of the article, the author deals with the surprising development of the so-called "special military operation", leading to a change in Russia's original plans. In the following parts, he discusses the way the forces of the warring parties are used in individual domains, applies the principles of warfare and discusses the possible causes of the operational failure of the Russian military forces. The article mainly uses data from open sources. Analysis, comparison, deduction and synthesis were used in its compilation. The overall intention of the author is to offer readers one possible view of the ongoing conflict and to motivate them to think about the nature and character of war. |
Impact of the New Technologies on CBRN Terrorist Threats: General Perspective and Perspective of Republic of CroatiaReviewed - ReviewIvana Cetina, Jugoslav JozićVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 119-139 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.04.119-139 Although the level of the overall CBRN threat in the world is currently considered to be low, there is a trend of a growing concern about CBRN terrorism. Various terrorist groups have shown interest in using CBRN materials to disrupt the global order and economy. The motivation and factors that influence the potential use of CBRN agents in terrorist attacks arise from the fact that CBRN agents have potentially high mortality and can cause serious consequences. A large number of potential dual-use (military and civilian) items as well as the introduction of new technologies in use can be utilized for the CBRN attacks and create a wide range of new possible terrorist (and military) threats. This paper provides a general overview of the past and current situations regarding CBRN terrorism, analyses some of current widely known new technologies that can be utilized for CBRN terrorist attacks and analyses the biggest potential threats from CBRN hazards. |
The use of modeling and simulation in the development process optimization of the Armed Forces of the Czech RepublicReviewed - ResearchJan Mazal, Jan Zezula, Josef Procházka, Dalibor ProcházkaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 140-158 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.04.140-158 The article contributes to a more efficient use of the theoretical, technological and application base, especially to the improvement of decision-making processes at the strategic level. It offers a methodological framework for solving the armed forces capability optimization problem by implementing modeling, simulation and operations research tools and theories. |
A Case Study of Defense Resource Management in a (Un)Sustainable Development PerspectiveReviewed - ResearchDaniela-Elena Hrab, Gheorghe MinculeteVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 41-62 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.03.041-062 The US military presence in Afghanistan has been the subject of retrospective analyzes that facilitated the identification and learning of important lessons for future military actions. This article analyses, through the case study method, the way defense resources were managed from a sustainable development perspective, focusing on the durable effects of the main projects aimed at ensuring this country's initial steps towards a sustainable development destination. As a result, this study points to the positive potential that the military instrument could have in a country's efforts to achieve sustainable development goals, highlighting the way that unsustainable management practices can compromise or even nullify the progress in this area. Consequently, the main product of this research is a model of unsustainable use of defense resources that decision makers should know and avoid in the future, to obtain long-term beneficial results. |
Do Economic Determinants Affect the Size of Military Spending?Reviewed - ResearchLenka Brigzalová, Vojtěch Müllner, Jakub Odehnal, Jiří NeubauerVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 63-83 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.03.063-083 The article aims to identify the dependence of military expenditures and selected economic determinants on the example of the V4 countries in the years 1999-2020. The following are selected as economic determinants: the size of the gross domestic product, the rate of inflation, the debt and deficit of the government sector and unemployment. Correlation analysis proved the expected relationship between the gross domestic product and the military expenditure of Hungary and especially Poland. The relationship between military spending and unemployment was confirmed for Poland, Hungary and Slovakia, the expected relationship between military spending and government debt for the Czech Republic. The linear regression model confirmed the positive effect of the gross domestic product on military expenditure in the case of Poland, the effect of the increase in military expenditure due to rising inflation in Hungary and the negative effect of increasing state indebtedness in the case of the Czech Republic. At the same time, the results did not confirm the uniformity of the factors affecting the size of the military factors in the analyzed V4 countries. |
Strategic Communications: From a Reactive Fight Against Disinformation Towards Comprehensive Use in Support of National Security and DefenceReviewed - ReviewVendula DivišováVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 34-53 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.02.034-053 The concept of strategic communications rose to prominence especially with the events linked to the Crimea annexation and Russian intervention in Eastern Ukraine. As such it has been mostly related to the reactive fight against disinformation and propaganda or other elements of the hybrid campaign. This paper aims to point to the much broader potential for the tool of strategic communications in support of goals in the realm of national security and defence, while it is understood as proactive efforts and specific mindset using the information effect to advance national interests. Based on the literature review, benefits of strategic communications beyond hybrid campaigns are identified also in the fields of foreign military operations, counterinsurgency, counter-terrorism, deterrence and crisis management. It describes the informational, particularly, the cognitive, dimensions of these security threats as well as of the measures to counter them. |
Constructive Simmulation: An Effective Tool for an Assessment of the Operational Effectiveness within the Cability Planning ProcessReviewed - ResearchJan Drozd, Josef ProcházkaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 54-70 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.02.054-070 The article outlines the outcome of a comprehensive researche aiming at the enhancement of decision making within the defence and operational planning processes. Both processes differ in purpose, neverthelles they are challenged by the very same problém to find solutions with maximum operational effectiveness of armed forces capabilities at minimum cost to achieve objectives. It applies constructive simulation namely the software instruments of MASA SWORD and assess its potential to support the process of capability requirements identification and validation of potential alternatives to achieve objectives. It provides reasonable evidence that constructive simulation is a valuable instrument to support the evidence based decision making within in the processes of defence planning and operations planning proces. Constructive simulation allows to identify the most suitable solutions in terms of both operational effectiveness and costs. |
Cognitive Hierarchy and IntelligenceReviewed - ReviewJozef Vojtek, Josef Říha, Miroslav ŠuhajVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 88-105 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.02.088-105 The article deals with the issue of the cognitive pyramid and the possible use of intelligence analysis in the context of gaining the understanding and wisdom of users of information using this pyramid. The cognitive pyramid is used to define the terms date, information, knowledge, understanding and wisdom that make up the various levels of the pyramid. The paper attempts to discuss concepts in different models of the pyramid. It briefly describes intelligence in the context of the use of intelligence by means of a cognitive pyramid. Intelligence is a special kind of knowledge. This article also seeks to explore how intelligence creation can be explained using a cognitive analytical pyramid model. |
Applicability of Multirotors in Czech Armed ForcesReviewed - ResearchPetr Žárský, Petr Hlavizna, Jakub HnidkaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 106-120 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.02.106-120 Authors of the paper present results of research in the area of deployment and operation of multirotors, i.e., autonomous aerial systems with vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) capability. Survey of Czech Army experts' opinions based on the Delphi method points to the significance of MINI VTOL UAS project undertaking - reconnaissance VTOL autonomous aerial system. The conclusion of the analysis is the identification of the primary applications of and requirements for (concept, system, and training) successful deployment of multirotors, with framing of existing issues of technical, acquisition/program and legislative nature, and determination of their importance. The paper also explores experts' views to the acquisition and operation of multirotors in Czech Army to achieve their full operational potential, certainly available in the future battlefield. Inconsistent architecture of information sharing was identified by experts as one of the most important issues with the highest likelihood of solution in the upcoming years. |
The Information War in Ukraine as a Part of the Military StrategyReviewed - ReviewJan MěřičkaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 21-37 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.01.021-037 This paper assesses the information war in Ukraine in the context of the military strategy. An influence of the information operation (disinformation and deception) presents the strategic tool. The author pragmatically analyses the information war from the military art perspectives and as a part of the strategy used for support of the combat operations. He identifies phases of the information war in the context of the war. The author expects and confirms the opinion that the information war is led by both external actors (the USA and the Russian Federation). Their top representatives are involving in the information war because they support their own interests. This paper has been written as a neo-realist case study. The balance of power concept is in accordance with the used theory, as well as with the key interests of the external actors. |
Material assets of the mobilization of Armed forces of the Czech Republic at the beginning of the 21st centuryReviewed - ReviewPetr DosoudilVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 71-91 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.01.071-091 This article focuses on the identification of key factors of material resources in the field of equipment, armaments and military vehicles within the Czech state needed for effective mobilization. The primary goal is to answer the question of whether the Army of the Czech Republic still has adequate supplies of these key resources and whether it has the ability to increase these resources in crisis situations without significant dependence on foreign imports. The above analysis revealed mostly sufficient stocks, but at the same time significant limitations were identified in some categories, especially in their technical and moral quality (obsolescence, respectively), especially in most types of military vehicles. The issue of dependence on foreign imports concerning raw materials then changes considerably, from the minimum (combat dress) to the almost maximum (ballistic helmet) level. |
Current Nuclear Strategies and Arsenals of the United States of America and the Russian FederationReviewed - ReviewAdam PotočňákVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2021, Vol. XXX. (LXII.): 23-44 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.30.2021.04.023-044 The article holistically analyses current strategies for the use and development of nuclear forces of the USA and Russia and analytically reflects their mutual doctrinal interactions. It deals with the conditions under which the U.S. and Russia may opt for using their nuclear weapons and reflects also related issues of modernization and development of their actual nuclear forces. The author argues that both superpowers did not manage to abandon the Cold War logic or avoid erroneous, distorted or exaggerated assumptions about the intentions of the other side. The text concludes with a summary of possible changes and adaptations of the American nuclear strategy under the Biden administration as part of the assumed strategy update expected for 2022. |
Free-Riding Problem in AllianceReviewed - ReviewJakub OdehnalVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. MC/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 49-60 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.25.2016.05.049-060 Long-term cuts in military expenditures of European allied countries caused growing differences within the Alliance which can be seen in uneven sharing of military burden and in behaviour called free-riding. The aim of this contribution is to define possible approaches to the freeriding identification and to analyse military expenditure development in relation to conclusions and recommendations declared at the NATO Summit in 2014. The results of military expenditure analysis identify only a small group of countries which, from a long-term point of view, follow the recommendations of the Alliance in the form of allocating a corresponding amount as percentage of GDP and in the form of a recommended structure of military expenditures. |
Experience from Canceled Sajkovac Base Extend the Czech Armed Forces Engineer CapabilitiesNonreviewed - Reviewnpor. Ing. Jan Hanudeľ, plk. doc. Ing. Pavel Maňas Ph.D., mjr. Ing. Jiří Štoller Ph.D., pplk. v.z. Ing. Vojtěch HanudeľVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2016, Vol. XXV. (LVII.): 102-113 The article deals with experience in closure of military bases in foreign operations. It follows in article Life cycle of military bases in foreign operations, published in Vojenské rozhledy Nr. 4/2009. The text of article presents current knowledge about the life cycle of military bases and general principles from the perspective of the latest NATO Handbook. The theoretical part of the article introduces weighting method of decision analysis, which compares current ways for the field bases closure. Authors describe findings from base closure Šajkovac that significantly influenced removal activities. |
Cooperation of Civil and Military Logistics in Military OperationsReviewed - ReviewDoc. Ing. Miroslav Cempírek, CSc., Doc. Ing. Miroslav Pecina, CSc., Ing. Miroslav Musil, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2015, Vol. XXIV. (LVI.): 144-158 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.24.2015.03.144-158 The article deals with the integration of outside resources into the process of support Forces in Military operations. The crux of this work lies in the illustration of 'place' and the role of Civil Contracting Supports in the Combat Service system of Armed Forces. It also accentuates the sense and complexity of Combat Service Support. The article analyses the advantages. disadvantages and risks for utilizating Civil Contractors in armed conflicts. The text respects this and acknowledges the benefit from experience of the NATO Armies in this field. In the closing part the authors formulate recommendations for the later boom of 'Combat Service' theory and practice. The effect and benefit of this article lies first of all in its suggestion of criteria for the selection of contractors. |
How to Prepare for Urban Warfare?Reviewed - Reviewkpt. Mgr. Karel Zetocha, Ph.D., nrtm. Tomáš KarásekVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 3/2015, Vol. XXIV. (LVI.): 172-189 | DOI: 10.3849/1210-3292.24.2015.03.172-189 Infantry company urban operations training experience shows that effective training requires interaction of doctrine with equipment and structure of units. NATO standards must be further developed at the national level to match the technology and organization of own units. Training requires elaboration of training manuals that contain specific tactical exercises for standardized training facilities. Experienced training instructors should focus on the preparation of organic units. Transferring experience from instructors directly to organic units is more efficient than preparing individuals in professional courses. |
Host Nation Support (HNS) in the Context of International Air Forces Exercises in the Czech RepublicNonreviewed - Othernadporučík Ing. Martin ŠkvařilVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2015, Vol. XXIV. (LVI.): 117-130 The article analyses the Host Nation Support (HNS) planning process in five separate phases according to the NATO procedures. The author emphasizes the importance, purpose and result of every planning stage. The main objective of the article is to apply general rules to the concrete examples of international air forces exercises. The author further identifies his comprehension of HNS formed in the specific conditions of the 22th Helicopter Base. The logistic planning process analysis is based on the experience from exercises Ramstein Rover and Ample Strike held in the period of 2012-2014. The paper is focused on exercises preparatory stages that create the basis for a successful accomplishment of the executive part. The results of the article present the trend of planning responsibility delegation to the tactical level and define the specifics of adapted planning process. The author's contribution may be used as a lead for the future application of the HNS concept. |
Unfulfilled Ambitions of Scottish Defence PolicyReviewed - OtherMgr. Bc. Ondřej SvobodaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2014, Vol. XXIII. (LV.): 102-108 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.23.2014.04.102-108 In the September Scottish referendum of its separation from the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the majority of Scottish voters decided against these efforts. But in case of success, Scottish nationalists originally projected considerable military forces. A five-million nation should have had defence budget of 2.5 billion pounds a year, which is in fact roughly a double of the Czech defence budget! During subsequent ten years after independence, the new Scottish Government planned armed forces of 15,000 regular and another five thousand reserve personnel. The article focuses on this rather unknown dimension of Scottish independence debate. |
United States and Russian Federation: Comparison from the Point of their Security and Strategic CulturesNonreviewedVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2014, Vol. XXIII. (LV.): 141-145 Jan Eichler, Lukáš Tichý: USA a Ruská federace - komparace z pohledu bezpečnostní a strategické kultury. Kompletní analýza bezpečnostní a strategické kultury USA a Ruska v letech 1991 až 2012. Brož., 318 str., ISBN 978-80-87558-16-4. |
Lightweight Armoured Vehicle S-LOV-CBRNNonreviewed - OtherIng. Bohuslav Res, CSc.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2014, Vol. XXIII. (LV.): 155-163 The paper describes a design concept of a lightweight armoured vehicle set "S-LOV-CBRN". The equipment of this set allows its crew to carry out a safe reconnaissance activities in areas with unknown situation under chemical, biological and radiological risks (CBRN reconnaissance), as well as the risk of contact with armed opponents. |
The Basics of Environmental Security in Military OperationsReviewed - ReviewDoc. Ing. Miroslav Cempírek, CSc., prof. Ing. Aleš Komár, CSc., Ing. Vladislav Vincenec, Ph.D.Vojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2013, Vol. XXII. (LIV.): 89-99 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.22.2013.01.089-099 In course of action, modern forces ought to be capable to safe living surroundings by the implementation of environmental protection into military planning and decision-making process. Traditionally it protects not only a location around military bases, training areas, but also in all operational area of deployed armed forces. This study therefore deals with methods of environmental protection and the so-called risk management to prevent damages that can't be remediated, both in the field of natural, cultural or historic sights and relicts. |
Operational PlanningMilitary artIng. Jaroslav KulíšekVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 1/2012, Vol. XXI. (LIII.): 56-78 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.21.2012.01.056-078 The article shows that Czech armed forces are supposed to develop planning mechanism according to the Alliance Comprehensive Operations Planning Directive (COPD) to be fully interoperable in operation planning process (OPP), namely in field operations planning in the framework of the multinational missions abroad. However, some problems persist at the operational level of crisis management, such as institutional arrangements for planning and commanding crisis operations, procedures pertaining to force generation, synchronization and activities coordination. The Czech Army Operational Planning Doctrine is still being developed. The purpose of this article is to inform on current state of affairs in operational planning with subsequent consequences to the results and reform recommendations by the White Paper on Defence. |
Intelligence Support of Personnel Recovery SystemNonreviewed - OtherJiří SvobodaVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 2/2019, Vol. XXVIII. (LX.): 108-114 Personnel Recovery intervenes to almost all areas of planning, preparation and implementation of military operations. One of the important areas of the personnel recovery system is the intelligence area. This article describes on the operational level the reasons and basic methods of intelligence support of Personnel Recovery during joint military operations. It introduces selected intelligence disciplines and explains the suitability of their use in the various Personnel Recovery phases. It also describes the intelligence activities related to post-reintegration phase and outlines the basic issues associated with the intelligence support of Personnel Recovery. |
A Look at Our Army Ten Years AgoHistory pagesPhDr. Antonín RašekVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2009, Vol. XVIII. (L.): 173-184 At that time, the base for plural societies in Eastern Europe was founded. Poland, the Czech Republic and Hungary joined NATO defence alliance. Serious global threats of economic, military, ecology, social, ethnic, religious, criminal characters were lasting. The important question of proliferation of mass destruction weapons was raised. The analyses of security situations in Europe and the World respectively proved that armed conflicts were mostly internal, in a form of civic wars, but demographically endangering bordering countries. Those threats were only discussed, namely nobody fully realized the threat of terrorism. Defence budgets were reduced, all people wanted to profit from the so-called peace dividends. Czech army was loyal to the state; it was not misused in inner political conflicts, which was regarded as something normal by the majority of Czech public. But there were many problems left, especially the role and engagement of the ACR in the following century. |
The Armed Forces in Institutional and Functional ConceptReviewed - ReviewLeopold Skoruša, Ondřej Horák, Radim Vičar, Tomáš ZbořilVojenské rozhledy / Czech Military Review Nr. 4/2022, Vol. XXXI. (LXIII.): 3-22 | DOI: 10.3849/2336-2995.31.2022.04.003-022 The article deals with the interpretation of the term "armed forces" in the context of the current legal system of the Czech Republic. The authors propose to distinguish between the armed forces in the institutional concept and in the functional concept. The essence of the solution is the interpretation of Section 3(1) of the Armed Forces Act (No. 219/1999 Coll.) in the functional concept, i.e. in such a way that the armed forces are understood to include soldiers assigned to the Ministry of Defence, military schools, the Military Police and the Military Intelligence. Another solution could be to add a paragraph to the Armed Forces Act stating that "The provisions on members of the armed forces shall apply mutatis mutandis to soldiers on active service assigned to the Ministry of Defence, military schools, the Military Police and the Military Intelligence." The aim of the article is initiation professional discussions about the issue in question, as well as indications of directions as to how it would be appropriate to solve the matter. |

